Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Kelly Churney
As residents who live in a landmarked building and who value the importance of these physical reminders of Palm
Beach’s unique history, we are truly shocked and saddened at the destruction of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse.
The loss of this unique structure will change the whole character of the Plaza and undermine the recent careful
remodeling of that part of our island as a special business and residential center.
The Preservation Society has always recognized that a building does not stand alone; it is part of a larger context
into which it is embedded. We cannot imagine that the society was consulted on this project.
Therefore, we ask: how did this happen? Will there be an investigation and those responsible held accountable?
Sincerely yours,
Bonnie E Litowitz, PhD
Norman S Litowitz, MD
2155 Ibis Isle Road #11
Palm Beach, FL

Received via email on 8.14.23:
I am dismayed that this historic building was bulldozed. What process was used to determine this destruction?
Diane Evans

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Landmarks Commissioners,
I am very saddened to see the extent of the demolition at the Royal Ponciana playhouse. It seems like an excessive
amount of commercial development will replace what was a beautiful historical space in Palm Beach.
While it is great to have a building renovated, it is equally important to ensure that neither the character of the
structure or its surroundings are denigrated.
I hope that the Town will be able to ensure that the character of our historic structures remains intact in the future.
Perhaps such large scale developers should pay for the Town to hire a representative to act on the Town’s behalf to
keep track of a project’s development so that these situations do not occur?
I also hope the Commission will reconsider instituting historic districts within the Town as soon as this is possible.
Thank you for your consideration and mindfulness in preserving our town.
Maisie Grace
Town resident

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Kelly,
I was surprised to see the pile of rubble that was the Playhouse. I don’t recall any discussions of its total distraction.
Was the community altered to this possibility? Something about this lacks transparency to the community and
particularly the Palm Beach Preservation Society.
I am eager to hear the explanation to better understand how this can happen.
Best,
Beatrix Kondor
3400 S Ocean Blvd
Palm Beach, FL

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Ms. Churney,
I was shocked to see images of the demolished Royal Poinciana Playhouse. How in the world
could this have happened in a community so strongly
focused on preserving our architectural heritage? Looks like the committees who approved
the restoration/renovation of the property were completely duped by the developer
or turned a blind eye to the proposal. In any event it is a great loss to the community. I will be
greatly interested to learn how the demolition was approved.
Sincerely,
Susan Schmeichel
66 Middle Road

Received via email on 8.14.23:
To the authorities …how unfortunate !
Please keep a watchful eye on another beloved Palm Beach landmark :
The Paramount theater building complex .
A second inadvertent demolition should not occur !!!
Thank you
Françoise Davis Mallow
139 sunrise avenue apt 311
Palm Beach 33480

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Ms. Churney,
I am emailing in response to this terrible news. It is the buildings of historic
significance that make a place unique and special. Please fix what made such a
travesty possible and return as much of this historic site back to its original form. And,
please, put the appropriate oversite in place so that this never happens again.
Respectfully,
Lori Geiger

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Good afternoon,
It has come to my attention that there is some ongoing concern about the demolition/reconstruction of the Palm
Beach Playhouse. As a resident of Palm Beach, I would like to express my support of the reconstruction team, the
Board of the new Playhouse, as well as architect John Volk.
This structure has sat vacant for twenty years, and while change is difficult, I trust that the plans for this state-of-theart
performance and entertainment venue are necessary to bring the level of arts and cultural events that Palm Beach
residents want! I have full confidence in the vision and attention to detail that has been expressed in the
straightforward visuals and plans to date.
So excited to watch the development of this site and to be able to access such a beneficial, thoughtful, and gorgeous
addition to our beautiful Palm Beach.
Warmest regards,
Marjorie Goldstein
2580 S. Ocean Blvd

Received via email on 8.14.23:
To All Concerned:
Please be advised of our support for ongoing renovation and restoration to The Royal Poinciana Playhouse. This is
an aging structure totally neglected over a long period. The Glazers and others have only the BEST intentions to
preserve as much as possible the integrity of the building. As restorations go, sometimes unforeseen complexities
arise that must be dealt with on the spot. I am confident they and their partners are making the correct decisions to
maintain the original structure as much as possible and to create a safe building. We ask not to delay the progress of
this wonderful project because we desperately need an on island multi-use venue. Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
Marlene Silver

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Hello to all:
I couldn’t have been more shocked when I drove into the back of the Royal Poinciana Plaza a few
weeks ago and saw what looked like total demolition of the Playhouse.
I stopped and parked my car and walked over to get as close as I could to look, because I could not
believe my eyes. Most of the building had been demolished!!!!! It looked like a Western movie set,
where a fake wall is a facade for buildings, but there is nothing behind.
How did this happen????
It seemed everyone was being so careful to ensure this would NOT happen.
Yet here it is, demolished, right under our noses!
This is shocking and very, very upsetting.
The people who did this need way more than to receive a fine. They need to rebuild what was there,
as exactly as possible, at their cost.
People cannot be allowed to get away with this behavior!
(I was a Palm Beach resident for 15 years and just recently moved across the bridge.)
Pam
Pamela Acheson Myers
1801 South Flagler Drive #902
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

Received via email on 8.14.23:
I am a resident of Palm Beach. It is outrageous that the historic Playhouse has been almost totally demolished! The
developer needs oversight though at this point the building is destroyed so I’m not sure what can be done.
Constance Rosenberg
2760 South Ocean Blvd, #511
Palm Beach

Received via email on 8.15.23:
Dear Ms. Churney and members of Council - decades ago, Jacqueline Kennedy, in an effort to preserve historic buildings in Washington DC without quashing architectural progress in the 20th Century, worked with architects, planners, and Congress to devise a way to preserve historic buildings and facades so as to retain the character of neighborhoods. This technique has been employed on a National scale ever since, particularly in DC, NYC, and Boston. Attached are several articles on this and a photo or two to illustrate. I hope you will keep in mind that a Public building must be safe for the public and that the creation of a state-of-the-art cultural center in the heart of Palm Beach will only reap huge benefits for the community, businesses, and the cultural life it will enliven.
With all due respect,
Mary Kathleen Ernst, Resident
Published by NEH (National Endowment for the Humanities): Shortly after moving into the White House in 1961, Mr. and Mrs. John F. Kennedy became intensely interested in plans afoot to redevelop Lafayette Square, opposite their new address at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. Several architectural firms, the U.S. Commission of Fine Arts, and the General Services Administration were the principal players, and talks centered on the style of new office buildings to be built there. Some camps favored a Beaux Arts structure, others, more modernist. Whichever style won out would have to be in harmony with the historic buildings surrounding the square, including St. John’s Church on the north and the White House on the south. Previously, President Eisenhower had also weighed in, suggesting that the historic Decatur House on the northwest side of the square and the Blair House on the southwest, both on Jackson Place, be spared and incorporated into any future plans. Mrs. Kennedy favored the winning plan that would create a seamless facade of nineteenth-century residences on Jackson Place, the western side of the square. The New Executive Office Building, built during the renovation, is set back from the square and rises unobtrusively above the row of town houses.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1994/05/29/jackies-washington-how-she-rescued-the-citys-history/5d59d26d-659d-451d-8303-e2f19c4a7175/
Mary Kathleen Ernst
MaryKathleenErnst.com
310 Via Linda
Palm Beach, FL 33480

Received via email on 8.15.23:
To Whom It May Concern:
I am writing to express my enthusiastic support for The INNOVATE project in Palm Beach. I firmly believe that this project will not only promote community growth but also enhance the cultural fabric of Palm Beach, all while preserving the special character that makes this town unique.
As a teacher at Palm Beach Day Academy for the past 17 years, I have always been passionate about providing my 5th-grade students with the best educational opportunities possible. When I learned about The INNOVATE and its vision for the community, I was excited about the impact it would have on the educational landscape of Palm Beach.
The idea of having resources, community spaces, and cultural events that The INNOVATE promises aligns perfectly with our commitment to fostering well-rounded, informed, and engaged students. The project's focus on growth, culture, and preservation are the values we aim to instill in our students and community.
Thank you for taking the time to read my email and to consider the overwhelming community support for the mission of The INNOVATE, and thank you for your endorsement.
Sincerely,
Katy Thompson

Received via email on 8.15.23:
To Landmarks,
This is particularly heartbreaking to me. Many years ago I was on the original Theater Guild that Pat Flynn started with Christopher Plummer and many other residents, all wanting to find money and support to renovate the theater. I had a couple of readings and cocktails at our house as well.
>
> So, from my point of view, this is outrageous to see this perfectly gradient 350 seat theater gone. So many fond memories of our first years in PB in the 1970s.
>
> The idea of banning the contractor/builder from continuing, although extreme, is the best answer to send a message to them and all future projects.
> We can never get it back but stop them in their tracks now.
> I’m on board in support of anything that can be done.
>
> All the best to you,
> Helen Guest
152 Wells Rd.

Received via email on 8.15.23:
I am writing in support of the preservation efforts and re opening of Palm Beach's historic Royal Poinciana Playhouse.
This is further testament to the importance of culture in our area. As a Jupiter resident in northern Palm Beach County-I am so happy to be living in an area of Florida which values and preserves architecture, history and the unique ecology of our country.
I believe that these efforts will bring back a vital part of Palm Beach's art and culture and can't wait to support this when it re opens.
Sincerely,
Susan Magrino Dunning

Received via email on 8.15.23:
Dear Ms Churney,
I am writing in regards to the demolition of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse. As a Palm Beach native, my heart used to swell every time I drove over the north bridge at the first glimpse of our beautiful island, The Royal Poinciana Playhouse. I was excited to hear that the Playhouse was going to be rehabbed and functioning again, however this demolition is not what the residents agreed to, nor expected. I have watched our island get completely overhauled- long are the days of old Palm Beach with pastel colored houses and little white fences. To allow one of the last iconic pieces of old Palm Beach- and a John Volk design at that- to be destroyed in this manner is heart breaking and frankly unacceptable. The town should have taken great care, supervision and responsibility to preserve this last shred of what Palm Beach has become beloved and famous for. How are we to trust that our island will maintain its integrity if the town simply allows builders to go unchecked and unsupervised? Demolition now, and ask for forgiveness later? Is this the new normal?
I urge you to share my deep concern with the town council and the landmarks commission. Please help us save our island.
Thank you,
Chelsea Mara

Received via email on 8.15.23:
Dear Landmarks Preservation Commissioners,
For every resident who has seen the state of destruction of the historic Royal Poinciana Theatre while crossing the North Bridge and those who have only seen the Civic Association’s photo, the reaction can only be shock and dismay. After listening to the Nov. 16, 2022 LPC presentation by the developer’s spokesperson, Alexandra Patterson, I was stunned to see there was no public comment and no questioning by LPC. However, with the lack of transparency or documents to support the statements made by the presenter, it is understandable there were no questions because the LPC did not comprehend what was to happen. No documents had been given to back up her assertions from these multiple consultants' reports which justified the destruction of the structure not included in this presentation. Where was the proof of muck soil? How did ‘restoration of the roof’ become demolition of the entire roof? Why were there no attachments showing past approval and how what the developer stated had to be done differed from what had been approved in the original certification of appropriateness? LPC was presented with a drawing that showed what remains(green line), what was demolished(orange line) and what was to be rebuilt (blue line). Shouldn’t the developer’s agent have indicated that the blue line-’to be reconstructed’ meant completely knocked down? It seems that this ’update’ meeting presented what the developer planned to do in such a way that the LPC-nor the public- could grasp the magnitude of the destruction. Had they done so, certainly they would not have allowed it to go forward without deeper investigation.
Is the drawing presented below the same as was presented when the project was approved? If this is a new drawing, then LPC should have been given more information, back up documents presented, discussed and voted on. The changes were presented as fact without comparison to what the original certificate of appropriateness included. The Town failed the residents by not requiring notification of this agenda item and by not supplying any back up documents to the LPC or to the public.
The developer’s agent presented a new walkway design for the restaurant and for the north side of the building as well as changes to the trash collection building. These were not in the original approval and should have been debated and voted upon as a modification to the certificate of appropriateness.
What has happened at the theatre is a cautionary tale for re-development of landmarked structures in commercial zones which are currently being promoted by the developers-specifically the Paramount Theatre and the Wells Fargo 6.5 acre site on Royal Palm Way. One wonders whether the lack of proof of justification for the extensive demolition presented to LPC and the Commission's lack of information or questioning the changes is a playbook for these other projects which are 'preservation-washing' in order to over-develop their sites. The developers involved in the Plaza and these projects care not one iota about the Landmark they are using to gain extraordinary financial benefit. Preservation of a landmark is nothing more than a shallow pretense to manipulate our representatives into permitting far more development -12,000 sq feet of unneeded or wanted commercial space, a 200 seat restaurant, no theatre but an event space under the guise of ‘ preservation'. It is cheaper to tear down than to preserve historic architecture..
One wonders if this extensive demolition was intentional. The owner of the Plaza(Spiegel) had shuttered the theatre by not renewing the theatre operator’s lease. This was intentional on the part of the owner. I believe demolition by neglect was the goal so that the theatre could be torn down and condos built on the site. Just such a project was proposed, advertised and flogged. However, many dedicated theatre supporters continued to fight for years and years to reopen the theatre while the owner continued to allow it to deteriorate. If the process that is supposed to protect these essential and iconic elements of Palm Beach is not more carefully overseen, we will have virtually nothing left of the architectural gems that distinguish Palm Beach from other sand, sea and palm tree resort towns.
Anne C. Pepper
333 Seaspray Avenue

Received via email on 8.15.23:
To Whom it May Concern,
We are writing in support of the renovation and advancement of THE INNOVATE at the former Royal Poinciana Playhouse, Palm Beach. For the last twenty years, we have been disheartened watching the historic theater at Royal Poinciana Plaza fall into disrepair with no plan for rehabilitation. We became enthusiastic supporters of the project when we learned about the current cultural arts multi-use theater restoration funded by Jill and Avie Glazer.
The current plan protects the legacy of the Playhouse and encourages community engagement and education. The leadership of the not-for-profit Palm Beach Cultural Innovation Center is committed to enriching and inspiring residents of Palm Beach, young and old. The project should be allowed to continue unencumbered and uninterrupted.
It is time for all community organizations to applaud the Glazer's vision for restoring the historic theater, THE INNOVATE at Palm Beach. We urge every neighbor and friend to recognize their unselfish and generous gift to their beloved home community.
Sincerely yours,
Susan & Edward Henkin
1801 North Flagler Drive
West Palm Beach FL 33407

Received via email on 8.15.23:
To the Mayor, Town Council & Landmarks Preservation Commission.
Palm Beach has an embarrassing void in the area of of the performing arts. We have to go “over the bridge” to Kravis to see/hear artists in a facility that uses 21st century technology to deliver top production values.
The island should have no less, and I hope the Town Council and Landmarks will continue to prioritize and facilitate the building of a world-class cultural arts center here using the plans that were carefully researched and developed by the UpMarket and Innovate/Glazer group team.
I strongly feel the Preservation Society has misrepresented the facts and tried to derail their proposed plan which is sound and has four parts:
1—RESTORE what is possible and up to code in this landmark building.
2–RENOVATE the parts that can support a 21st century high-production value facility.
3–DEMOLISH and REBUILD the parts of the playhouse that must come down according to the present-day Florida building code. I have looked at the color-coded pdf presentation presented to Landmarks last November showing which walls had to be rebuilt and which had to be braced, and was approved. The permit that was granted confirmed there was no over-building despite the Preservation Society saying there would be.
4–Lastly, the proposed construction would support the NEW SUPERSTRUCTURE NEEDED to create a successful 21st century world-class cultural arts center.
The existing shape and size are NOT served by preserving more of the current shell even if it were all up to code — which it is not. Why?
Because….
—Different acoustics are needed.
—The flexibility to create different seating configurations is essential
in order to create the varying environments for pre-eminent soloists, intimate world-class chamber music, symphonic music, theatrical productions that could be staged in the round, as well as events for young children that might have them seated on the floor.
—A larger restaurant is needed so patrons don’t have to go off-site.
The existing shell can’t accomplish any of these goals. Thus demolishing and rebuilding portions of the playhouse are a must.
Sincerely,
Christine Ansbacher
170 Chilean Avenue
Palm Beach, FL 33480

Received via email on 8.14.23:
To Whom It May Concern,
I am writing this letter first on behalf of the Center for Creative Education to express our enthusiastic support for the establishment of the new Palm Beach Cultural Innovation Center at The Innovate. We believe that this initiative holds significant promise for fostering creativity, collaboration, and growth within our community and beyond.
As a cornerstone for cultural innovation, the center's strategic location on Palm Beach Island will undoubtedly attract a diverse range of talents from various cultural organizations. This convergence of minds will not only facilitate the exchange of groundbreaking ideas but also create opportunities for cross-disciplinary partnerships.
Moreover, the center's commitment to education and outreach is commendable. By engaging with local schools, universities, and organizations, the Innovate will inspire the next generation of innovators, equipping them with the skills and mindset needed to tackle complex problems with creativity and resilience.
In conclusion, I personally support the establishment of the Palm Beach Cultural Innovation Center at The Innovate. We firmly believe that this initiative will have a transformative impact on our community, fostering innovation, collaboration, and prosperity. We are excited about the possibilities that the center brings and are eager to participate in its programs and initiatives.
Robert L. Hamon President and CEO

Received via email on 8.15.23:
Dear Mayor Moore, Members of the Town Council, and the Landmark Preservation Commission:
I am writing in support of the ongoing renovations to the Royal Poinciana Playhouse and the partnership between the Town of Palm Beach, WS Development, and INNOVATE Corp. The planned restoration, as approved by Town Council and the Landmark Preservation Commission, not only represents the rebirth of a dormant Town jewel, but it will also bring world-class cultural offerings to enrich life in and around Palm Beach and serve as a public gathering place that will better connect Town residents to Palm Beach and attract positive attention that will keep Palm Beach at the forefront of a rapidly-changing world and cultural scene.
Our mission at the Chamber Music Society of Palm Beach is to connect, transform and inspire the world through extraordinary artists and performances, to build community, and to amplify the impact of our unique art form through innovation, social responsibility, and educational programming. We have a big and bold vision to extend the power of chamber music performance and education across the south Florida region and beyond, and to do so from right here in Palm Beach, out of the beautifully restored Playhouse.
Our organization is very excited by the positive changes planned for the Playhouse. It is our understanding that the developers have acted in full accordance with approved plans and that certain historical elements that were structurally flawed will be recreated to preserve the qualities that make “the Royal” so special. With this restoration, resources we once dedicated to securing costly venues and navigating difficult production limitations will now become more available to help amplify our impact and mission. With The INNOVATE we will be able to reach a larger audience and engage more students through educational programs - bringing them into the venue to experience incredible live music on the island, expanding their world views in ways that will help unlock their full potential.
We see the space as a hub from which a multitude of organizations and individuals will engage and reinforce a community that embraces and spreads our shared values of respect, cooperation, commitment to excellence, and a spirit of innovation. These are all values that we hold at CMSPB, and values that we have witnessed at the forefront of our collaboration with INNOVATE Corp. and WS Development as they have thoughtfully, thoroughly, and inclusively planned this project.
Thank you for your support and your due diligence in ensuring the best possible outcomes for residents of Palm Beach and the many people who contribute our excellent quality of life.
Sincerely,
Ahmad Mayes
Executive Director

Received via email 8.14.23:
This is a very sad action that has happened to Palm Beach.
How did the developer get the permits to destroy the Playhouse like that.
The permits should be reviewed and any changes should be fined. It looks like they just destroyed every thing to make there own interest: Waterfront Restaurant . Should they be allowed to continue?
This reminds me of Penn Station in New York. We have to take action in the future. There should be a Historic Committee that can look at plans and vote and have a real say in what can be done to Historic Buildings.
Thank You for your interest
Marianne Vlazny

Received via 8.14.23:
As a long time resident of Palm Beach living in the Palm Beach Towers, I was appalled of the total demolition of the Playhouse.
Who in God's name is in charge that allowed this to happen? Perhaps a former employee of the Town now working for a rapacious developer?? Winking and nodding at methods of manipulating the zoning system to achieve a result never allowed in the light of day?
This should cause an almighty uproar and whoever allowed this demolition to proceed should be terminated.
The entire process seems ridden with ineptitude and/or malfeasance.
Sincerely
James B Donahue

Received via email 8.14.23:
To Whom It May Concern:
I am writing to express my support for The INNOVATE project in Palm Beach. This project holds significant potential for the community's growth and development.
I have lived and worked in Palm Beach county for over 35 years and I remember going to the Royal Poinciana Playhouse to some really great performances. The Playhouse has sat in disrepair for over 20 years and now it finally has a chance to become a proud part of the landscape of Palm Beach again for residents and visitors. This would not be possible without Avie and Jill Glazer and their dedication to Palm Beach. They have a vision to bring the former playhouse back to life and I am personally very excited about the new Palm Beach Cultural Innovation Center at The INNOVATE.
This new cultural resource will bring exciting programs and educational activities to Palm Beach. It will create jobs, attract investment, and enhance our town's arts and culture offerings while preserving its unique character.
I urge you to consider the overwhelming community support for the mission of The INNOVATE and its positive impact for generations to come.
Thank you for your endorsement.
Sincerely,
Mary Lewis Moews

Received via email 8.14.23:
TOPB
I happened to be by the Playhouse
When work began, and decided to enter the lobby which was off limits Saw some chandeliers, balcony railings, carpet, etc. and photographed, and was so excited that it was happening and hoping that some of these original objects would be repurposed, with the restoration.
Now I’m doubting that any of this has been saved.
Do we know??
Would like to comment also
On the proposed restoration/renovation of The Paramount theater in my neighborhood We should insure that something like what has occurred at The Playhouse, does not happen at The Paramount I am supporting the restoration, not the destruction of the theater But with Robert Stern Architects, as designer, I feel secure, if it is approved.
Please insure, as it comes to approval, that this is the case.
Thank You
John V Calcagno
170 N Ocean Blvd
Palm Beach

Received via email 8.14.23:
To Mayor Moore, Members of the Town Council and Members of the Landark Preservation Commission:
We are incredibly fortunate to have the collaboration of the vision and generosity of UpMarkets and the INNOVATE/GLAZER group, who have assembled the very best team in order to provide our community with a world-class cultural arts center.
I was saddened to read the latest email blast from the Preservation Foundation. This is an organization that prides itself on KNOWLEDGE, STEWARDSHIP and CULTURE and I am curious to know how such an organization can create such negativity regarding the rebirth of a Cultural Institution for our community.
As I have reviewed all information available to the public, I see no fault other than a conflict of the true meaning of KNOWLEDGE, STEWARDSHIP AND CULTURE . It is these very values that define humanity and that is what creates a true community.
I fully support the UpMarkets/INNOVATE/GLAZERS team with great hopes that we will all applaud them for their commitment and generosity to all of us!
With respect and hope,
Vicki Kellogg

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear Sirs,
I am writing in response to the email circulated by the “Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach relative to the Royal Poinciana Playhouse renovation. As I am sure that you are aware, in 2022 both the Town Council and the Landmarks Preservation Commission approved the restoration and renovation of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse. The approval was granted after more than eight years of study, soil analysis, evaluation of current building condition as well as the evaluation of the best contractors to conduct the renovation and restoration. I have attached the plan approved in November 2022 as well as the January 2023 permit.
I am horrified that – at this late date and after careful analysis by you, our elected officials – the Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach will attempt, without knowledge or authority, to delay or prevent the continued renovation of this historic building. The renovation is being done in complete compliance with the approval granted by Town Council and Landmarks Preservation Commisssion. The newly renovated Playhouse will be a major addition to the arts institutions of Palm Beach – and represents the best use (and best recognition) of this historic structure – while maintaining the integrity of the original building to the degree possible. Please let the construction proceed as well researched, well planned and well executed.
FYI, I am a resident of Palm Beach and care deeply about the preservation of the architectural and cultural character of the community.
Sincerely yours,
Paul Block
3100 South Ocean Boulevard
Palm Beach, FL

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear Sirs,
For over twenty years I have lived at the Palm Beach Towers and witnessed the efforts of the citizens to preserve the Playhouse and seen many potential purchasers deterred by the need to ‘preserve and protect’ the fabric of the building. How then, can it be possible that the building is no longer standing? Two side walls only and a facade?
Who authorized this demolition, what oversight did the town have on this project? Surely after so many years, someone was aware that some overzealous demo was a possibility? So very disheartening.
I look forward to hearing your comments.
Yours sincerely,
Marion Gay

Received via email 8.15.23:
To whom it may concern:
I’m shocked and disappointed to read about the beloved Palm Beach Play House!
How a landmark building could just slip away is appalling!
Saving a few walls id hardly enough to preserve the original design.
A great loss!!
With heartfelt disappointment
Sally MacGuire
4333 N Ocean Blvd.
Gulf Stream Fl. 33483
561 455 4529
18 Wildwood Lane
Darien, CT 06820
203 655 7166

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear Mayor Moore and Members of the Palm Beach Town Council:
We're pleased to provide you with an update on the Royal Poinciana Playhouse arts center project, reflecting our core mission of creating a vibrant hub where the arts flourish, enriching our entire community.
We're thrilled to introduce our newly appointed Executive Director, Cheryl Mendelson, a dynamic leader whose experience perfectly aligns with our goals. Cheryl is already forging vital connections with community stakeholders and arts leaders, paving the way for exciting collaborations and partnerships that will drive our shared mission forward.
As you are aware, the building will be a state-of-the-art, sustainable venue, featuring a flexible 400-seat black box theater, multiple event spaces, a lifelong learning center, top-notch patron amenities, and advanced technology for live-streaming performances. Our diverse programming, spanning music, dance, cabaret, theater, film, humanities, arts education, and lifelong learning, will make The INNOVATE a beacon of artistic excellence and a premier destination for cultural experiences.
Beyond being a performance venue, The INNOVATE is a vibrant home for our community. It's where local nonprofit cultural organizations thrive, where children explore artistic expression, and where audiences of all ages gather. By fostering this environment, we're enriching our cultural tapestry, supporting economic growth, generating jobs, and boosting local businesses and hospitality.
We're deeply committed to our community's aspirations and the enduring impact of this visionary endeavor. Together, we're creating a legacy—a cultural cornerstone that unites our community and celebrates the transformative power of the arts for generation to come.
We look forward to providing ongoing updates as we realize the promise of this transformative project. Thank you for your invaluable support.
Sincerely,
Avie and Jill Glazer

Received via email 8.15.23:
To Whom It May Concern:
As the Founding Artistic and Executive Director of Ballet Palm Beach, I am very excited about the new Palm Beach Cultural Innovation Center at The Innovate. This new cultural resource will bring exciting programs and educational activities to our region. We plan to collaborate with the organization and have already met with their CEO to discuss future work together.
I was very honored to be invited to some of the initial meetings concerning the planning of the The Innovate, formerly the Royal Poinciana Playhouse.
How wonderful it would be to have another cultural center in Palm Beach to add to the overall cultural experiences for Palm Beach residents and their guests. Palm Beach is already a travel destination, how exciting for it to be a cultural destination as well!
Very truly yours,
Colleen Smith
Founding Artistic and Executive Director
Ballet Palm Beach

Received via email 8.15.23:
This developer bulldozed this iconic treasure rather than restored a historical building. I live at Waterview Towers, directly across the intracoastal and the demo was done within a few days. Cheaper to bulldoze rather than the agreed restoration. The developer should be denied any anticipated tax deduction or Credit by taking away the declared historical value of the remaining facade and structure.
Best,
Rona Heymann CPA

Received via email 8.15.23:
Please share the message below with Mayor Danielle Moore, members of the Town Council, and the Landmarks Preservation Commission:
My husband and I, residents of Palm Beach, are fully in support of the renovations to the Royal Poinciana Playhouse as approved in the plans.
Sincerely,
Mary Jacobson

Received via email 8.15.23:
To the Palm Beach town council
From Chris Kellogg
Regarding the Poinciana Playhouse
It's a sad note that the preservation foundation would send out such an unprofessional and despicable message to its members to come to town council and complain at this late date after all the many reviews done by the town and its departments before allowing permitting to proceed on the restoration project. Well this is a time to rejoice not complain.
Palm Beach is very fortunate after 20 years that no one was willing to tackle this major project that innovate stepped in to restore this condemned building. Their stated reason for doing this was to make a contribution to the community they loved. So aren't we lucky beneficiaries of their largess.
Innovate as committed tremendous management time and effort and millions of dollars to bring this magnificent multi arts venue back to the town of Palm Beach. The town should look into a way of showing it appreciation of this tremendous gift.

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear People,
I have been following the story of the renovation of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse and I’m distressed to learn that the Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach is trying to delay this renovation. I remember that in 2022 the Town Council and the Landmarks Preservation Commission approved this restoration. I also remember that there were eight years spent studying soil analysis, evaluation of the current building condition and the evaluation of the best contractors to do the renovation and restoration.
Why would you try to delay or prevent this important renovation? It is being done with total compliance regarding all of the guidelines that the Town has put forth. Palm Beach needs more arts/culture. I, as a resident of Palm Beach, want to see the Playhouse restored in all of its glory so the residents of the Town can enjoy the wonderful cultural opportunities that the Playhouse will provide.
Why are you creating this problem after all of the approvals have been set in stone.
Please let the construction move forward, as it should.
Sincerely,
Valerie Salembier
3100 S Ocean
PB, Fla

Received via email 8.15.23:
As former Director of Education at the Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach, the unwarranted partial demolition of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse is a major concern and unacceptable. What happened????
Janice G. Owensc

Received via email 8.15.23:
To Whom It May Concern:
This email serves to respond to the circulation by the Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach concerning the Royal Poinciana Playhouse renovation.
As you know, in 2022 the Town Council and the Landmarks Preservation Commission approved the restoration and renovation of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse. The approval was granted after more than eight (8) years of:
-careful study to determine what is in the public interest and best serves the needs of the Town of Palm Beach and the community,
-soil analysis and environmental issues,
-evaluation of current building conditions, and
-the evaluation of the best contractors to conduct the renovation and restoration.
As a resident of Palm Beach County, I am disappointed and disturbed to hear that – at this eleventh hour and after a most careful study and analysis by elected officials -- the Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach will attempt, without knowledge or authority, to delay or prevent the continued renovation of this historic building. The renovation is being done in full compliance with the approval granted by Town Council and Landmarks Preservation Commission.
As you appreciate, the newly renovated Playhouse will be a substantial contribution to the cultural, social, and educational life of Palm Beach, and it exemplifies the best use -- and best recognition -- of this historic structure. It is in the public interest to allow the construction to proceed.
Respectfully Submitted,
Anthony E. DiResta

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear Mayor, Town Council and Preservation Society,
I have lived in Palm Beach for over 10 years and have always been puzzled why the Royal Ponciana Playhouse was sitting empty when our community needed such a space for cultural events.
I understand that the process of restoration is difficult and fraught with emotion, However if a building has sat vacant for years and found to need significant shoring up for renovation, then that process must be done for safety.
I understand that all permits and full disclosure have been made to the proper authorities in Palm Beach and that approval was granted for the renovation of the Playhouse.
Please do not delay the completion of this project because of the optics of what is needed to create a safe building… all of which were approved.
Patti Silver
170 Chilean Avenue

Received via email 8.15.23:
To whom it may concern,
Could someone explain in detail whom and how we went from a renovation to a demolishing of the Playhouse. Where is this going for what reason. Who is behind it and what are the real future plans. This is creating more of a distrust in town of all this so called growth. It is another example of losing the town. Growth is fine but I. Moderation. The old with the new. The old is what made Palm Brach Charming.
Looking forward to hearing back from you.
Respectfully,
Deborah Koepper

Received via email 8.15.23:
Attention: Landmarks, Town Council and the Mayor,
I am writing with great enthusiasm about the renovation of The Royal Poinciana Plaza Playhouse. After so many years of being dormant having it brought back to life and offering theater and unbelievable dining on the water - what an absolute delight! I could not be more excited to spend many evenings enjoying shows. As Palm Beach has evolved over the years, the culture offerings to rival other destinations have been less than and with this, we are really offering the best to our community.
Thank you for your support of such an important project.
Best,
Bailey Horn

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear Ms. Skier,
I was so disheartened when I came across the north bridge and saw the devastation of our beloved Playhouse. Town Council member, Julie Araskog, use the perfect word to describe how she felt when she first saw the demolition; “Gobsmacked”!
I am a resident of the Palm Beach Towers, the Royal’s closest neighbor. My sense of the Royal’s leadership is they would rather apologize than ask for permission. Early in the process, they put a series of dumpsters under the windows of the residents of Palm Beach Towers who live on the south side of the building. Were they ever given permission to disrupt the lives of numerous tax paying residents for their own convenience? Did they not even consider the impact of this selfish decision? We have suffered through late nights of bottles being emptied in metal dumpsters and trash trucks picking up before the sun is up. The process takes two trucks, and can take as long as half hour. Not a great way to start the day. Then, valets using car alarms to find cars, which indicates a lack of a system, and training, that is not appropriate for a residential neighborhood. Very noisy trucks make deliveries before 7:00 AM. Not to mention the sewer drains being emptied and the side walk power washing that starts at 6:30 AM.
If they are disrespectful neighbors now, what will they be when they are fully operational? This is a disaster waiting to happen, because the rules do not seem to apply to this organization.
Would it be possible for the Preservation Commission and the Town Council work as a team to provide more significant oversight of the Playhouse project? From the residents perspective, it does not appear there is much communication between the two leadership bodies of the town. And to be very direct, the Royal does not seem to be playing by the rules set down for them, so they need more watchful eyes.
Perhaps, they should be asked to cease their project until a complete review can be done and avoid another shocking event, or worse, a result that is not at all what they presented to the town.
Sincerely,
Denise M. Budnitz
44 Cocoanut Row
Palm Beach

Received via email 8.15.23:
To Whom It May Concern:
I have had the pleasure of seeing the future plans for the Palm Beach Cultural Innovation Center at The Innovate and, as someone who grew up in Palm Beach County, I believe our area is fortunate to have the vision and investment of Avie and Jill Glazer for this facility.
I have experienced the same commitment to breathing new life into an abandoned theatre with Milton and Tamar Maltz who put over $30 million into the Maltz Jupiter Theatre (once the Burt Reynolds Dinner Theatre) in Jupiter, Florida. This season, I will begin my 19th year running the organization which has grown to become the only LORT B+ regional theatre in the lower half of the United States. We just completed a $42 million renovation. Our theatre generates over $56 million in economic activity. Open theatres create great communities with strong culture.
The Palm Beach Innovation Center will be an amenity to the surrounding community from which many not-for-profits will benefit. We have all watched it sit empty for two decades and no one has found a useful way to bring it back until now. Let’s not live in the past. You have a dedicated team to move this space forward. Personally, I think they need encouragement, not obstacles.
Thank you for considering my humble point of view.
Warmest regards,
Andrew Kato
Producing Artistic Director/Chief Executive The Maltz Jupiter Theatre

Received via email 8.15.23:
Madame President and Gentlemen--I live south of this construction and am really quite appalled at the inconvenience it has caused. How is it possible that this private project was granted a permit authorizing such disruption to traffic on a public road and increasing the possibility of accidents at this site? Is the permit public record? Was any environmental study done to make sure the road remains stable after completion--particularly if there is flooding during a hurricane?
Although I am assuming/expecting that the owners are paying for the 24-hour/7 days traffic directors, all the equipment, etc. and have provided the Town with more than adequate insurance, this project goes way beyond normal construction. If there was a public hearing on this, I am sorry I missed it!
Is there an end in sight? I do not mean to sound belligerent--the Town and administrators do great work for us residents making the permitting of this project and the resulting burden on residents and service providers even more inexplicable. Thank you, Linda Sosnowitz

Received via email 8.16.23:
To: Landmarks Preservation Commission, ARCOM and Town Council members
We have lived in an eighty year old Monterey Colonial home on Monterey Road for about forty years and are concerned about the "demolition gone rogue" of the land marked home next door to us at 284 Monterey. This demolition is occurring to build a guest house for the owner of a large lake front property, and includes the enlargement of a minor violation of the side set back ordinance that will have the entire east wall of this guest house closest to our residence located in the side yard set back so that guest noise will be far away from their host but very close to our living area.
I may even have photos of this tear down that were taken earlier when the destruction of the residence appeared to becoming a total demolition. Unfortunately, it appears that the only way to stop and deter other unauthorized demolitions is to impose the strictest of penalties and sanctions, not just the ones that are just considered to be a cost of doing business by violators who know that they can't be forced to recreate what they have destroyed.
284 Monterey isn't even the worst example of the Demolition Derby on our street. We understand that 249 Monterey, the largest and most attractive example of Monterey Colonial style on our street, is destined for total demolition. We have heard that as a result of an unenforced agreement with the Town, a Fast Buck Flipper made millions from concessions permitted by officials and then his agreement to preserve our street's flagship Fatio designed home was never enforced and a subsequent owner is being allowed to send its remains to decorate the county land fill. How could this happen in a town that prides itself on preservation.
This may not be the final outrage because I have been advised that the individual who benefited financially from this debacle is now a member of Landmarks Preservation. If this is true,we can only hope that they will recuse themselves from any vote regarding demolition of land marked buildings or any other properties that may have architectural significance.
Admittedly, some of the facts regarding 249 Monterey are not clear because efforts to obtain written documentation were not successful.
Finally, we wonder what is the future of preservation efforts in Palm Beach if The Royal Poinciana Theater, along with 284 and 284 Monterey are dust in the wind.
Thank you for your assistance in preserving the beautiful and irreplaceable architecture of Palm Beach and standing firm against those interests that would demolish our treasured land marks for their personal gain.
Sincerely,
Pamela Dunston
282 Monterey Road

Received via email 8.15.23:
Dear Mayor, Town Council, and Landmarks Preservation Commission,
I am writing to you to express my concern with the reports that are circulating claiming there has been overdemolition to the Poinciana Playhouse. I am a registered Architect and also a Board Member of the Palm Beach Chamber Music Society. As you may know the new Playhouse will be the home of the Chamber Music Society. We are extremely thrilled with the newly created design for the structure and know it will be a huge asset for the Town of Palm Beach once completed.
I have reviewed the approved Construction Plans for the project and they clearly indicate which walls are to be removed, repaired, and rebuilt. The demolition is going along exactly as it was planned and approved by the Town. I am writing to you to offer my total support for this project and look forward to seeing it completed as scheduled.
Thank you,
Brian P. Brady, AIA

Received via email 8.14.23:
Dear Mayor Moore, Town Council Members, and Landmarks Preservation Commissioners,
With a heavy heart I write this letter as a long-time resident of Palm Beach with family roots dating from
the early twentieth century. My grandfather and great-uncle both built houses (Amado and Louwana)
that were designed by Addison Mizner in 1919. Both houses are landmarked and still stand having been
completely and sensitively rehabilitated in the last 20 years.
When I was a young girl, my grandfather knew well John and Jane Volk, and spoke much of the new
Royal Poinciana Plaza being built. John Volk was well-regarded and designed so many important
buildings in this town. I have personally owned two and came to know him personally as an adult. John
came back to my first house in 1980, which he had built in 1948, and drew up the plans for a new
loggia.
John Volk completed the Royal Poinciana Plaza and the Playhouse in the late 1950s. I cannot believe
that I am old enough to have watched the Playhouse being built and lived long enough to see it
demolished. I am perplexed as to how such a modern, well-constructed building was sentenced to
demolition at less than 70 years of age when so many buildings that are much older are still standing
proudly.
To my knowledge, the Landmarks Preservation Commission never voted nor were truly made aware of
the developer’s decision to demolition the Playhouse. Who is responsible for signing off that the
Playhouse could be torn down? And the same for the North Fire Station and the house designed by
Marion Sims Wyeth at 284 Monterey Road?
The residents of Palm Beach need transparency. We need every project involving a landmark building to
be overseen with the utmost care, throughout the construction process, as they are rehabilitated and
brought back to life. If we don’t get transparency now, on what happened at the Playhouse, the North
Fire Station, and 284 Monterey Road, wholesale demolition of landmarked buildings will be the constant
moving forward.
It is utterly shocking that the Playhouse has only the East wall still standing. Especially after so many
years of debating and fighting for the right thing to happen here. We waited so long for the Playhouse to
finally become a vibrant part of our community again only to lose it in the blink of an eye.
Now that it is gone, perhaps it will be put back as a replica of what it once was, as was originally
conceived by John Volk. Even if it is, it will be a copy (if you will, like a Disney World). Is this what our
Landmarks program has become? Landmarked buildings being demolished because it’s cheaper to
knock them down rather than secure their foundations and reinforce their walls?
I ask the Town Council and Landmarks Preservation Commission to please study this seriously. There
must be some kind of recourse to stop developers from just demolishing important buildings and
cashing in on what was our beloved beautiful town.
Most Sincerely, Pauline Pitt

Received via email 8.14.23:
If and when the stability of the structure became risky during demolition, did the developer have an
obligation to stop and get further emergency approvals? If so, what are the repercussions of failing
to do so?
If not, what do we need to do to fix this loop hole?
So sad, but leaving the scared frame is worse. We want the playhouse rebuilt in accordance with the
plans you (finally) approved.

Received via email 8.14.23 from Kathrine Palmer:
Appalling how could this have happened??

Received via email 8.14.23:
To the town council,
As a resident of Broward I enjoy all the arts Palm Beach offers and especially their historical architecture and
landmarks. What a shame that you did not recognize the importance and value this playhouse has to all Florida
residents. And how was this demolition allowed?
I hope the Palm Beach historical society will delve into this unfortunate occurrence and disregard for an historic
performance institution.
Sincerely,
Amy Fread

Received via email 8.14.23:
Dear Mr. Churney and other involved individuals, It is indeed disheartening to see what has been
done in the “dead of summer” to the iconic Royal Poinciana Playhouse when it must have been
presumed no one would notice. Just like the enormous building going up behind the Christian
Science Church in WPB the only possible answer for this is that someone with power is being
silenced for some reason. It is very disturbing and should be looked into!!! I have been in Palm
Beach for over 40 years and am dismayed to see the changes allowed during that time. Obviously,
some were necessary and others as the two I have mentioned MAKE NO SENSE! Alice Hanley

Received via email 8.14.23 from Maureen Conte:
I did read in yrs past when there were so many rallying cries to renovate and re open the Playhouse,
that it was virtually impossible due to electrical and other major issues. Maybe that is why it was
torn down; but yes, they had to have had permission from the Town to do so, I would think!

Received via email 8.14.23 from Penelope Irwin:
Hello Kelly:
Two obvious questions, yet unclear.
1. What were the guidelines for approval for the site, along with the permits requested - and who
set the guidelines? Did the developer ignore the approved guidelines?
2. Were any of the interior features salvaged for later restoration use?
I will be out of town, or I would certainly attend. Not only am I a resident of Palm Beach, I am also a
designer who is in complete shock for this gorgeous building.
Anything I can do to help, please reach out.
Penelope

Received via email 8.14.23:
We are devastated by this news.
We have been hoping to see a revival of this facility.
Another example of people doing what they want without
Caring about history.
Very upsetting.
Paul Jetty
Frank Marketti

Received via email 8.14.23:
to The Town of Palm Beach
The Royal Poinciana Playhouse
- this demolition is a tragedy - and it is essential to appoint an official body to investigate forensically the workings
behind the decision and timings to demolish - and whether the persons who pressed the start button had any vested
interests whatsoever .
- this casual demolition not expected in a ‘traditional’ civilised law-abiding town like Palm Beach! It must not be
allowed to become the ’norm’.
Christopher and Louise Lewinton
The Villas Worth Avenue Palm Beach.

Received via email from Natasha Lester on 8.14.23:
It is a horror! My heart is broken.It is so painful to see this picture! Here in Florida we don't have too
many historical places,like playhouse.It was our treasure.
In my mind I want to scream....How we could let it happen,people!
Now it is too late,very sad.It was a lesson to fight to save our landmark before such things
happened.Now it is only hope that walls will be restored to similar,how it was before.Yes,it will not
be the same,but It is better than nothing....

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Antonette,
I am writing this letter to you in a dismayed state. The utter destruction of the Playhouse this past summer needs to be addressed
by all of us Palm Beachers, as our heritage is seemingly being destroyed at a very rapid rate.
I moved with my family to Palm Beach in 1960. John Volk built three houses for my Mother, Lilly Fuller, and I knew both Mr. & Volk very well, as they were personal friends. I remember the Royal Poinciana Plaza being built, and went there frequently when completed. Every day in the Shiny Sheet, we would see, in glamorous black and white
photos, Frank Hale, Mary Sanford, and, who would become my beloved in-laws, Walter and Barton Gubelmann, attending the many
cultural events staged there. This was the Palm Beach that attracted people from all over the world.
Although the Plaza fell into a time of disrepair, the architecture of John Volk sustained its original elegance. I was glad that, several years ago, someone had the desire to bring the Poinciana Plaza back to its former glory. The result has been a wonderful return to a high quality experience of shopping and dining. The fact that the Plaza could be revived without architectural changes to Volk’s vision, speaks volumes to his understanding of our community and its needs. Therefore, I was not disturbed by the desire to revive the Playhouse. In fact, I look forward to returning to the theatre of many happy memories. But, now that it has been completely taken down, what will we be returning to? John Volk is no longer in a position to give
our community what it deserves.
It seems to me that what attracts people to Palm Beach is being destroyed by some of those same people. We, as Palm Beachers, need
to protect and defend our heritage, before it gets taken away from us. As fines do not seem to be a deterrent to those that commit these grievous destructions, what about making it a criminal offense? Fraudulent use of permits, for one ? Non-divulgence of conditions if work exceeds the permits, as another? In our litigious world, it seems to me there should be a serious deterrent and some accountability, to this crime against our architectural heritage.
Please consider this plea for help in protecting what Palm Beach really is, a small town created by its forefathers for its residents, and sometimes, tourists!
Sincerely,
Kate C. Gubelmann

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Good morning. I was a member of the Landmarks Preservation Commission from 1996-2004.
Gene Pandula,Jaquie Alberan,and Jeff Smith we’re on the commission with me.
Sometime during that period a developer wanted to change the status and usage of the playhouse.
My husband who is an attorney and I dug and read many documents related to the playhouse. We
found the actual words that prohibited the structure from demolition or changes in usage .
You can imagine how shocked and sadden I am at what has taken place. Certainly an abuse of
power. I now live at the Palm Beach Towers and have to see daily what a horror is becoming of a
“restoration “.

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Hello,
As a devoted former ballet student at Imperial Studios and, having performed at the beloved Palm Beach
Playhouse under the Direction of Frank Hale, and Joanna and Ted Kneeland, in many productions as a
child, I feel extremely saddened and disappointed at the decision to destroy this beautiful playhouse and
cultural center of the world. I still advocate ardently, Culture and the Arts in my life, as my formative years
at the Playhouse and Imperial Studios at the Palm Beach Towers were treasured memories and very
memorable experiences for me and my life. I do have beautiful Programs of performances, i
at the Palm Beach Playhouse if you are interested in seeing them.
Sincerely,
Pamela De Fina

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Hello Kelly,
My name is Joel Henson, a long time West Palm Beach resident, now living on North Flagler near the
Flagler Memorial Bridge. On my nightly runs across the bridge, I have been able to observe the
incremental over-demolition of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse. As a resident who takes interest in
protecting the cultural and historical roots of Palm Beach, I am saddened to see this destructive
overreach of developers and wanted to share my thoughts with the Town Council.
As we've seen across Palm Beach, and even more so in West Palm Beach, these developers are all
too eager to do away with the old and meaningful to make way for new, soulless architecture, all to
make a few bucks from the affluent Palm Beach demographic.
My question is how was there such a lack of oversight that this was allowed to take place? From my
understanding, this demolition far exceeds the initially submitted plans, however, I may be incorrect
in that conclusion. Moreover, regardless of their original intent, I wanted to voice the concern of
citizens of PB and WPB who are definitively opposed to the precedent being set here: the tearing
down of historical landmarks just for the sake of new business ventures. Especially business ventures
that lack depth and character, and never once benefit the local populace. I see it as an unfortunate
turn and a marring of the history of our area.
Please take note that these are irreversible changes to our city. Though the Playhouse and other
landmarks like it may not matter to City Development, those of us who have lived Palm Beach
County for many years and take pride in her history, are disheartened and angered over the extreme
and swift changes that are doing away with our historical landmarks.
Thank you for hearing my concerns and allowing me to voice them to you.
Best to you,
Joel

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Hello,
I would suspect they are doing the same required in LA when I lived there facade to be left and the
new building used it as the entrance.
This was true as well when I lived in Philadelphia, in certain historically designated areas.
Sincerely,
Lee-John Sobering

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Kelly and Landmarks Commission Members,
I write this as a resident not as a Council Member.
I am thoroughly saddened and in disbelief over the state of the Playhouse. The overwhelming demolition that
apparently was not understood by the LPC, The Preservation Foundation, and others is inconceivable to me.
I listened to the “update” from Alexandra Patterson in November 2022. I did not understand from her one photo
that the Playhouse would be destroyed. It appears that there was no back-up for the meeting or a request for a
modification. There was not any notice.
In my opinion the presentation was not transparent as the Preservation Foundation, the LPC and other qualified
individuals did not understand what Alexandra Patterson and the applicant intended. There was not a request for
modification, a discussion, or a vote, but just an update. How can this be for a Landmark that has included hundreds
of voices from Town residents in the past to preserve this treasure? Why was there not more scrutiny?
I ask myself and would like the Town and the Applicant to explain how this treasured Landmark that survived years
of attempts to tear it down (with overwhelming participation from the public) disappeared without notice, a
modification, or a true understanding of it by the LPC, Preservation Foundation and others.
The LPC safeguards our Landmarks. How could they not have been apprised of this change or intent to knock down
the entire Playhouse without a discussion, back-up with elevations, a thorough discussion, or proper notice?
I think there needs to be an investigation and thorough explanation into how this happened. Who allowed a
Landmark to be annihilated if not the LPC? Was the applicant forthright in their intent and discussions with the
Town’s staff? The Public and those who fought to preserve the Playhouse deserve answers.
Thank you,
Julie Araskog
1490 Via Manana

Received via email 8.14.23:
Dear Preservation Foundation and Landmarks Commission, During a short visit to Palm Beach in late July I passed
through the parking lot one afternoon in front of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse and saw the wrecking crew in full
swing. I wondered at that time that the demolition was looking very aggressive but assumed everything was in
control by those in charge.
All I can say is that it seems the boundaries were over stepped.. but what can be done now as it is probably too late?
It seems the Landmarks Commission should have been on top of the schedule proactively but I’m really not familiar
how these various entities interact so I hesitate to be critical. This is a tragedy indeed as this jewel box of a theater
will be hard to resurrect.
Respectfully yours,
Barbara Price
400 South Ocean Blvd

Received via email 8.14.23:
How could this have happened with you
In charge?
Lynn Tone
Former member

Received via email 8.14.23 from Joyce Mantyla:
WHAT TRAGIC MISCOMMUNICATION HAPPENED
TO DESTROY THIS FAMED PB LANDMARK?

Received via email 8.14.23 from Mary Azqueta:
Good Morning: I am a resident of Palm Beach since 1961.. I have grown up on this island and still live on this
island.. I was raised here with my family on Queens Lane and my mother is still living at 96 in Ocean Towers.. She
never left the island because this is where we live, we know, we are comfortable, we have places we know, it is a
one of a kind paradise. I went to shows in the playhouse, rehearsed for shows, sat in red velvet seats, ate in the
restaurant and waited for years to see what would become of such a special town place.. My husband who also has
lived here 60 plus years is also surprised as we drove over the bridge and saw the shreds of a place we considered a
home staple of hope. We are saddened that a destruction truck could come in and destroy such a gem.. and for
what? another development that we see all around us? We also grew up in the Paramount, watching movies, and
being upon the privileged to have such a fascinating fabulous special Place. With all the possibilities and unlimited
funds developers seem to have in this town, why they want to use minimal imagination and the quickest way to
destroy and build another of what every other community has baffles me. If only this is a prayer and a beg for
someone to consider saving our island with some legendary respect for our heritage, this is my request. I know there
are others that have been here a lifetime and find it embarrassing to see the power of money to destroy what we have
had and wish to keep because their wallet is flashy. Im sorry the memories of what we had in the play house and its
doors will never be opened to the generations to come on what was such a unique place.

Received via email 8.14.23:
Dear Preservation:
With all due respect I think your opinion misses, both the purpose and point, of this almost total demolition,
completely.
First, any building that has become structurally unsound must restore its structural integrity.
Secondly, a partial demolition, large or small, “guarantees” that its replacement will keep the building’s character
and history.
In other words, a partial demolition, especially of a history property, is usually a hugh plus, not a minus.

Received via email 8.14.23:
Good Morning Everyone,
I hope to find everyone well,
As a business owner in Palm Beach since 2017, i wanted to express my gratitude to you and WS
Development for making progress in the renovation of the Playhouse.
My shop is across from the playhouse, and i know it will add a lot of romance and authenticity,
Just wanted to share sincerely my thought to you,
Thank You,
Sincerely,
Stéphane Crémieux
CREMIEUX MENS SHOP
Royal Poinciana Plaza

Received via email on 8.14.23:
I am shocked and very upset about the demolition of the John Volk Playhouse.
Years ago we had gone through this whole process, where the town people signed petitions to save the Playhouse
from demolition. The people won and the house was preserved.
Was this demolition done without a permit? If it was , what are the consequences and penalties?
I know that when historic or landmark houses were demolished without a permit they had to be built back, exactly
the same, at least on the outside, and in the same footprint. One example of that is Stephen Schwarzman’s house.
I hope town council and the preservation society will look into that precedent and act accordingly and immediately.
According to law, this seems to be willful destruction.
I will sign any petition that You may want to send around to every one who is a resident of Palm Beach.
We cannot allow this kind of thing to happen because it will also send a message to contractors and people in
general that it is OK to ignore the laws of Palm Beach.
This is a very serious offense, please act quickly with a severe response.
Sincerely,
Mai Hallingby, Harrison

Received via email 8.14.23:
To whom it may concern -
I am writing in support of the inspiring work being accomplished by Avie and Jill Glazer and the
leaders involved with the rebirth of the former Royal Poinciana Playhouse. I have been working with
the Glazers for more than a year and a half to create an arts plan for the Palm Beach Cultural
Innovation Center at The Innovate. This plan included the formation of a new 501(c)3 organization to
lead and manage a performing arts center and local resource for the residents of The Town of Palm
Beach.
The building has been empty for more than two decades, and in my capacity as former CEO of the
Cultural Council of Palm Beach County I often lamented the lost opportunities that this empty and
fallow facility presented. I am very enthusiastic about this new arts and cultural resource for the
Town and grateful for the Glazers' substantial personal investment, without which it would not be
possible. While at heart I am a preservationist, I am also a realist. The old theater building was in a
state of disrepair and its outdated interior design was too far gone to preserve, leaving the only viable
option to rebuild as closely to the original as possible, a plan that was fully approved and permitted by
the Town long ago.
Respectfully,
Rena Blades

Received via email on 8.14.23 from Jane M. Dommerich:
I, too, was shocked every time I drove by the Playhouse and saw that there was almost nothing left and I wondered
why?

Received via email on 8.14.23:
If the Council allows the demolition of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse to go unpunished, everyone may do whatever he/she pleases. The Council, its decisions, and town regulations will become irrelevant. The Four Arts will assume that it may demolish its Rovensky and O'Keeffe buildings and
build new and better ones at much less cost than renovation without referral to the Council .
If the Council is to maintain any authority and respect, it must prohibit any construction on the site as an example to others who may be tempted to such outrage. Make it into a city park. At the very least, leave it as it is now for everyone to see and wonder.
Randolph H Guthrie
Chairman
The Society of The Four Arts

Received via email on 8.14.23 from Tracy Ward La Violette:
shocked. horrified. not sure what else to say. where are all the materials from the demo? can they be reused for the
rebuild. i find it astonishing that this was allowed to happen in front of everyone's eyes.
Tracy

Received via email on 8.14.23:
Dear Ms. Churney,
I hope this note finds you well. I am writing to express my enthusiastic support for The Playhouse project, here in the Town of Palm Beach. As an employee of one of the tenants at the Royal Poinciana Plaza, I believe that the redevelopment and opening of the Playhouse is
crucial for the growth and prosperity of the town.
Reopening The Playhouse will bring about numerous benefits that contribute to the cultural, social, and economic well-being of our community. I can attest that upon the announcement of the reopening, a large number of our patrons, who are local town residents, were excited about the prospect of having a newly reimagined Playhouse. Some of these discussions touched on what we as a community stand to gain. One being the cultural enrichment achieved by exposing our residents to a wide range of artistic expressions. These expressions foster creativity and expand cultural horizons. Some missed the sense of belonging and unity when the old Playhouse shuttered. Having such a meeting place allowed residents from
diverse backgrounds and ages to connect over a common interest in the arts. In recent years, the town has seen an influx of younger families that represent our future. The Playhouse will serve as a space to preserve traditional art forms and performances that might otherwise be forgotten over time. Reopening the Playhouse offers the opportunity to reflect the community's values, aspirations, and creative spirit, as well as adding to the town's unique character. Additionally, as a business member, we are looking forward to the Playhouse
contributing to tourism and boosting the local economy.
In short, The Playhouse will enhance the fabric of the community by providing a space for artistic expression, entertainment, and social engagement. It will contribute to the town's cultural vitality, social cohesion, and economic growth, making it a valuable asset for residents and visitors alike. In light of the above, I kindly urge you to consider the Playhouse as an essential component of our town's fabric and economy. I believe that any initiatives, programs, or policies that promote and protect local businesses will have a lasting positive impact on our community.
Sincerely,
Debbie Pettersson

Received via email on 8.14.23:
As a property owner in Palm Beach and part-time resident, I was shocked to see that the Royal Ponciana Playhouse
was almost totally demolished. Prior to this we had heard that it was going to be restored to his former glory. I have
been so excited about this. Please know that the citizens of Palm Beach are concerned and outraged over this.
Ginger Griffin, 340 Cocoanut Ray.

The relentless assault continues on the cherished charm of the Palm Beach landscape. The near total demolition of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse, despite its landmarked status, is the most recent and most publicly visible example of developers evading any possible restraints imposed by Arcom, the Landmarks Commission, or Town Council. Closer to my home, in fact, across the street is another more modest example. 284 Monterey Road, a charming Bermuda style bungalow and a landmarked house was virtually demolished by the new owner. Natural disasters may be beyond our control but is there no will or way to curb the man made destruction of our island?

I urge all town agencies to work together to assure that all redevelopment projects are carefully vetted and then monitored for compliance.
Developers should be assessed onerous penalties for any breaches. The tragedy of the Royal Poinciana Playhouse is a warning for the proposed Paramount development. Let us not compound this tragedy.

Carol Franklin
1105 North Lake Way